For the uninitiated,
Aereo is a two-year-old company that picks up television signals and sends them to the Internet-connected devices of Aereo subscribers, all without permission from or payment to the broadcasters who provide the programming. The broadcasters, including Walt Disney Co.’s ABC, Comcast Corp.’s NBC, CBS Corp. and 21st Century Fox, argued that Aereo is an illegal operation because it violates the networks’ exclusive rights to transmit their shows to the public.
On June 25, 2014, the broadcasters won.
Keach Hagey writes on The WSJ, that this is most like the death knell for Aereo, and it very well could be. Which is a terrible thing for consumers. While anyone is free to install an antenna on their rooftop or rig up their own version of Aereo at home and do everything that Aereo was giving them, it is likely that they may not want to invest ~ $200 or $300 doing that. Or, they may live in an apartment or house where installing an antenna is difficult if not downright impossible.
So the reason they liked Aereo and were willing to pay Aereo a handful of dollars every month is because Aereo made it very convenient to do what each American resident is allowed to 100% legally. Tap into and if they want, record and view over-the-air programming from anywhere, at anytime.
In effect then, the Supreme Court outlawing convenience, in the name of copyright law that was written for a different era. And since it’s not the SC’s job to write new laws, Congress must ideally do that and protect the consumer’s rights. But for that to happen, consumers must group together and fund tens of millions of lobbying and get such a law written and passed.
Good luck to anyone waiting for that day.